Recruiting KPIs
December 24, 2023
min read

Recruiting KPIs

Krissy Davis
Krissy Davis

Recruiting is the lifeblood of any successful organisation. It helps identify, attract, and hire the best talent to drive business growth and success. But how do we measure the effectiveness of our recruiting efforts? That's where Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) come in. 

Recruiting KPIs are essential metrics that offer significant insights into the entire hiring process. By tracking and evaluating these KPIs, we can identify the strengths and weaknesses of our recruitment process, which can help us make data-driven decisions and improve our hiring efforts. This article will explore the importance of Recruiting KPIs and how they can play a vital role in optimising your hiring strategy. So, whether you're an HR professional, a hiring manager, or simply curious about the world of recruitment, let's discuss why these metrics are essential for success.

What are recruiting KPIs

Recruiting KPIs are specific metrics used to measure the effectiveness of your hiring process and the performance of your recruiting team. They help you understand how well you attract, qualify, and hire the right talent for your organisation.

Do recruiting KPIs matter? 

Absolutely. Recruiting KPIs are crucial for any organisation that wants to hire top talent efficiently and effectively. Here's why:

  1. Measure progress: KPIs provide objective data to understand how your recruiting efforts are performing. You can compare current metrics to past data or industry benchmarks to identify areas for improvement.
  1. Identifies issues and optimises processes: Analysing KPIs can reveal friction points in your recruitment process, like high drop-off rates at certain stages or long time-to-hire. This helps you refine your strategy and streamline the flow of candidates.
  1. Demonstrates value: Tracking KPIs allows you to quantify the impact of your recruitment efforts on business outcomes. This can help justify budget allocations and gain buy-in from stakeholders.
  1. Helps make data-driven decisions: KPIs guide you to prioritise your resources and focus on activities with the highest return on investment. For example, identifying the most effective recruiting channels can help you allocate your budget accordingly.
  1. Attracts and retains talent: By demonstrating a data-driven approach to hiring, you can showcase your professionalism and commitment to attracting top talent. Additionally, KPIs can inform your employee value proposition and improve new hire retention.

List of recruiting KPIs - what they mean and how to measure them 

Here's a breakdown of some of the most essential key recruiting KPIs, their meaning, and how to measure them:


  • Time to hire

Time to hire is the average time it takes to fill a position, from opening the job to hiring someone. A faster time to hire can mean cost savings and a quicker return on investment.

  • Cost per hire

Tracks the cost of finding and hiring a new employee, including advertising, recruitment fees, and onboarding expenses.

  • Source quality

Assesses the effectiveness of your different recruitment channels (e.g., job boards, social media, employee referrals) in bringing in qualified candidates.

  • Qualified candidates per opening

Measures the number of applicants who meet the essential skills and experience requirements for the role.

  • Application completion rate

Tracks the percentage of people who start but don't finish the application process, indicating potential friction points in your onboarding process.

Quality of hire:

  • Offer acceptance rate

Measures the percentage of candidates who accept your job offer, indicating the attractiveness of your company and compensation package.

  • New hire retention rate

Tracks how long new hires stay with your company, providing insights into the effectiveness of your onboarding and integration processes.

  • Performance reviews

Evaluating the performance of new hires in their first few months can reveal potential gaps in your recruitment and selection process.

Additional KPIs:

  • Submit-to-interview ratio

The submit-to-interview ratio measures the percentage of applicants who move on from the initial submission stage to an interview.

  • Interview to offer ratio

Indicates the conversion rate of candidates who interview to receive an offer.

  • Employee referral rate

Tracks the number of new hires referred by existing employees, highlighting the strength of your company culture.

Choosing the right mix of KPIs for your organisation depends on your specific goals and priorities. Monitoring numbers and data is important to see how well your hiring process performs. By doing this, you can find ways to improve it and use the information you gather to make smart choices about hiring people in the future.

How to record recruiting KPIs

Choosing the right recording method is crucial for efficient and accurate KPI tracking. Here's a deeper dive into your options:

  1. Manual Tracking

Going the manual route is great because you won’t need extra tools or software to start, keeping the initial cost low. Plus, you can customise data collection to fit your needs. However, there are a few drawbacks to manual tracking. The process tends to be time-consuming, which can be a drag and might lead to mistakes. Dealing with a lot of data also becomes tricky, making it challenging to manage efficiently. And, since there’s no automation, you’ll have to do the analysis and reporting manually, which adds to the workload.

  1. Applicant Tracking System (ATS):

An ATS automates data collection and can seamlessly fit into your recruitment flow. Plus, it offers handy reporting and analytics tools, providing built-in reports and dashboards for easy KPI analysis. It's also a win for data accuracy, reducing errors and keeping data consistent. And when it comes to volume, it scales well, handling large amounts of data efficiently. However, there are some things to keep in mind. There's an upfront cost for the software and potentially ongoing maintenance fees. Also, getting the hang of the ATS might require some training for your team due to its complexity.

  1. Integration with HRIS:

Linking your recruiting system with an HRIS offers a holistic view by merging recruiting data with other HR information, giving you richer insights. It also enhances data quality by breaking down silos and ensuring consistency across all systems. Plus, it streamlines reporting, making data analysis and reporting in talent acquisition much easier. However, Integrating different systems can get complex and might pose technical challenges. Also, sharing data across systems requires strong security measures to safeguard sensitive information, adding a layer of consideration regarding data protection.

How to choose the best recording method

The best recording method is the one that best suits your specific needs and resources. Here’s a list of various factors to consider:

  • Company size and recruitment volume: Large companies with high recruitment volumes will benefit from the automation and scalability of an ATS or HRIS integration.

  • Budget and resources: Manual tracking might suit smaller companies with limited resources, while an ATS or HRIS integration requires larger investments.

  • Technical expertise: Setting up and using an ATS or HRIS integration might require technical skills within your team.

  • Data security: Ensure the chosen method complies with data privacy regulations and protects sensitive information within your organisation.

How to interpret recruiting KPIs 

Effectively interpreting your recruiting KPIs can give you valuable insights into your talent acquisition process, help you make data-driven decisions, and ultimately help you build a more robust and successful hiring strategy. Remember, consistent analysis and adaptation are key to continuously improving your talent acquisition efforts and attracting top talent for your organisation.

Here's a guide to help you interpret your data:

  1. Analyse trends and patterns

Look beyond individual data points and focus on trends over time. Are your KPIs improving, stagnating, or declining? Identify patterns across different KPIs. For example, a high time to hire might be correlated with a low application completion rate, suggesting friction points in your application process.

  1. Compare your data to targets and benchmarks

Did you achieve your set KPI targets? If not, what factors contributed to the gap? Benchmark your data against industry averages or competitors to assess your performance relative to others.

  1. Consider the context

Don't interpret KPIs in isolation. Consider external factors like market conditions, economic trends, and specific hiring challenges for certain roles. Qualitative data like candidate feedback can provide further context and explain quantitative KPI trends.

  1. Delve into details

Analyse data by specific departments, job types, or recruitment channels to identify areas for improvement. Use segmentation to compare KPIs for different talent pools or candidate demographics.

  1. Take action and adapt

Don't just analyse, act! Use your KPI insights to identify areas for improvement and implement targeted solutions. It's important to regularly check how well you're doing and make changes as necessary to make sure you're still heading in the right direction.

Here are some additional tips for interpreting recruiting KPIs:

  • Focus on leading indicators: Track KPIs that predict future outcomes, such as time to interview or interview to offer ratio, to identify potential issues before they impact your hiring success.

  • Don't rely on a single KPI: Use a balanced set of KPIs to paint a complete picture of your recruitment performance.

  • Communicate your findings: Share your KPI insights with stakeholders to gain buy-in for improvement initiatives.

  • Celebrate successes: Recognise and celebrate positive KPI trends to motivate your team and maintain momentum.

How to measure the success of Recruiting KPIs

Measuring the success of your recruiting KPIs involves tracking the numbers and understanding their impact on your overall talent acquisition goals and business objectives. 

To effectively measure recruitment success, it's important to define clear criteria for each recruiting KPI and set achievable targets based on current performance and industry benchmarks. Assessing the impact of KPIs on business outcomes by comparing data with industry benchmarks and designated targets can help determine effectiveness. To make data-driven decisions, adapt and refine KPIs regularly and communicate insights effectively to stakeholders. 

By following the steps in this article and continuously analysing your data, you can effectively measure the success of your recruiting KPIs and ensure they are driving your talent acquisition efforts towards achieving your organisational goals. 

Looking to hire tech professionals? 

The recruiting experts at WeAreDevelopers have pre-screened 1000s of tech candidates to ensure you have access to a highly skilled pool of IT talent. And the best part? You only pay when you’ve successfully hired someone! 

Schedule a meeting with one of their recruiting experts today and easily recruit your next best tech professional.  


#Wanted and #Misunderstood: A Developer Survey 2023 (Full Report)

Download now

#Wanted and #Misunderstood: A Developer Survey 2023 (Full Report)

Jetzt downloaden